MARKET COMMENTSEPTEMBER 8, 2014CAPITAL MARKETS RESEARCHMoodys Analytics markets and distributes all Moodys Capital Markets Research, Inc. materials. Moodys Capital Markets Research, Inc. is a subsidiary of Moodys Corporation. Moodys Analytics does not provide investment advisory services or products. For further detail, please see the last page.S&P at 2,000. So What?The S&P 500 recently topped 2,000 for the first time in its history, putting an exclamation point on a remarkable recovery for US equities since they collapsed during the financial crisis. Yet, with regard to long-term results and the value lost to inflation, the performance of stocks leaves something to be desired (Figure 1). Though the current credit market outlook is challenged by low rates, past returns on credit have frequently been comparable to equities and came with much less volatility. And the major stock indices are an imperfect measure of the health of the business sector and the economy, despite the attention bestowed on them.4006008001000120014001600180020002200Figure 1: Nominal vs Real S&P 500 Index ValuesS&P 500 Stock Index Real* S&P 500 Stock Index*Adjusted against the GDP price index, Source: S&P Dow Jones, BEALong-term equity returns are lacking The S&P 500 closed just above 2000 on August 26, marking a stellar 40% advance since the end of 2012 and 28% gain over the prior record set in the expansion that ended in 2007. On the surface, this trend would seem to point to tremendous performance and bright prospects for US industry. Yet, adjusting the S&P 500 against the GDP price index, the S&P index is still just a bit short of the high set in the year 2000. Over the intervening 14-year period the annualized return for the index was a skimpy 2.0% in nominal terms and 0% in real terms. The period of these underwhelming figures was dominated by two extreme market busts that have damaged the appeal of equities despite the eventual recoveries.Naturally, starting an investment period at a high point will depress results. Instead, if you take the results just over the past decade, the S&P 500 returned 6.0% annualized nominally and 4.2% when adjusted for inflation. Those rates did comfortably outperform growth in the US economy over that period of 3.6% nominally and 1.6% in real terms. Yet more pedestrian credit market investments performed comparably or better over this period, with less violent swings. The Barclays US High Yield Index returned 9.7% annualized in nominal terms in the past decade, while the Investment Grade Corporate Index expanded by 5.7%.Moodys Capital Markets Research, Inc.Author Ben Garber 1.212.553.4732 benjamin.garber@moodys.comCAPITAL MARKETS RESEARCH2 SEPTEMBER 8, 2014 MOODYS CAPITAL MARKETS RESEARCH, INC. / MARKET COMMENT / MOODYS.COMOver longer stretches of time, investment grade corporate debt has frequently outperformed equities. Starting...